Research Review–HMB, A New Review Published


Up now is a great review of the sports supplement HMB. I met Jacob briefly at ACSM and he hinted at some new data on HMB and it is released now.

You may remember HMB as being popular about 10 years ago (or maybe not). There were some great studies (not sure I agree with that) on it, but in reality it just never seemed to pan out. It did not help that the patent on it was held by Dr. Nissen–Hmmm. This is not inherently bad, but makes you want to dig a little deeper. See the patent HERE for yourself. Although HMB has sort of stood the test of time as it is still around and from a research stand point, we could learn some cool stuff.

Background
HMB, or “beta-hydroxy beta-methylbutyrate”, is a second downstream metabolite of the amino acid Leucine and is produced naturally by the human body. HMB is produced from a metabolite of leucine, called ketoisocaproate (KIC), by the enzyme KIC-dioxygenase. If you have been around for a bit like myself, you will remember KIC as a supplement too. Personally, it did not do squat for me and tasted absolutely horrible and was stupid expensive. I worked at a supplement store while I was going to college the first 8 years and got it for dirt cheap when it did not sell it. It was back when they sold things in actual glass containers! I am feeling old now.

I will hold any future thought for now since the review is very comprehensive and all the others did their homework on it. Writing a review is a MUCH bigger pain in the butt than most realized, so kudos to them for all the outstanding work on it. It allows people like myself (and you) to sit back with a good cup of dark coffee and read the most recent work without spending hours and hours combing through 100+ papers.

Here is a link to the FULL study

Effects of beta-hydroxy-beta-methylbutyrate (HMB) on exercise performance and body composition across varying levels of age, sex, and training experience: A review.

Wilson GJ, Wilson JM, Manninen AH.

Division of Nutritional Sciences, University of Illinois, Urbana, Illinois, USA. gwilson@abcbodybuilding.com.

ABSTRACT: The leucine metabolite beta-hydroxy-beta-methylbutyrate (HMB) has been extensively used as an ergogenic aid; particularly among bodybuilders and strength/power athletes, who use it to promote exercise performance and skeletal muscle hypertrophy. While numerous studies have supported the efficacy of HMB in exercise and clinical conditions, there have been a number of conflicting results. Therefore, the first purpose of this paper will be to provide an in depth and objective analysis of HMB research. Special care is taken to present critical details of each study in an attempt to both examine the effectiveness of HMB as well as explain possible reasons for conflicting results seen in the literature. Within this analysis, moderator variables such as age, training experience, various states of muscle catabolism, and optimal dosages of HMB are discussed. The validity of dependent measurements, clustering of data, and a conflict of interest bias will also be analyzed. A second purpose of this paper is to provide a comprehensive discussion on possible mechanisms, which HMB may operate through. Currently, the most readily discussed mechanism has been attributed to HMB as a precursor to the rate limiting enzyme to cholesterol synthesis HMG-coenzyme A reductase.

However, an increase in research has been directed towards possible proteolytic pathways HMB may operate through. Evidence from cachectic cancer studies suggests that HMB may inhibit the ubiquitin-proteasome proteolytic pathway responsible for the specific degradation of intracellular proteins. HMB may also directly stimulate protein synthesis, through an mTOR dependent mechanism. Finally, special care has been taken to provide future research implications.

Any comments, let me know.
Rock on
Mike N

Post to Twitter

3 Comments

Performance Research for June: Protein Synthesis–How to Use Research to Get Hyooooge

So I am a few months behind on research updates, but have no fear as more good stuff is coming. For June some great studies on pre and post protein and carbohydrate beverages, NSAIDs (like Advil) and their effects on muscle growth, and some molecular mechanisms in action.

Be sure to check out my previous post HERE on protein synthesis (adding muscle) and what you can do to maximize it based on bleeding edge research.

If all this crazy research makes your head spin back like a Pez dispenser and just want to get the plan and get started today, check out Jimmy Smith’s Physique Formula.

Let’s get to it

Differential effects of resistance and endurance exercise in the fed state on signaling molecule phosphorylation and protein synthesis in human muscle.

Wilkinson SB, Phillips SM, Atherton PJ, Patel R, Yarasheski KE, Tarnopolsky MA, Rennie MJ. McMaster University.

Resistance (RE) and endurance (EE) exercise stimulate mixed skeletal muscle protein synthesis. The phenotypes induced by RE (myofibrillar protein accretion) and EE (mitochondrial expansion) training must result from differential stimulation of myofibrillar and mitochondrial protein synthesis. We measured the synthetic rates of myofibrillar and mitochondrial proteins and the activation of signaling proteins (Akt-mTOR-p70S6K) at rest and after an acute bout of RE or EE in the untrained state and after 10 wk of RE or EE training in young healthy men. While untrained, RE stimulated both myofibrillar and mitochondrial protein synthesis, 67% and 69% (P

Conclusion: Chronic resistance exercise (wt training) or endurance exercise training modifies the protein synthetic response of functional protein fractions, with a shift toward exercise phenotype-specific responses, without an obvious explanatory change in the phosphorylation of regulatory signaling pathway proteins.

My notes: sounds like the SAID principle in action! The body is adapting specifically to the stimulus (exercise)

Essential amino acid and carbohydrate ingestion prior to resistance exercise does not enhance post-exercise muscle protein synthesis.

Fujita S, Dreyer HC, Drummond MJ, Glynn EL, Volpi E, Rasmussen BB.University of Tokyo. Ingestion of an essential amino acid-carbohydrate (EAA+CHO) solution following resistance exercise enhances muscle protein synthesis during post-exercise recovery. It is unclear whether EAA+CHO ingestion prior to resistance exercise can improve direct measures of post-exercise muscle protein synthesis (FSR; fractional synthetic rate). We hypothesized that EAA+CHO ingestion prior to a bout of resistance exercise would prevent the exercise-induced decrease in muscle FSR and would result in an enhanced rate of muscle FSR during post-exercise recovery. We studied 22 young healthy subjects before, during, and for 2 hr following a bout of high-intensity leg resistance exercise. The Fasting control group (N=11) did not ingest nutrients and the EAA+CHO group (N=11) ingested a solution of EAA+CHO 1 hr prior to beginning the exercise bout. Stable isotopic methods were used in combination with muscle biopsies to determine FSR. Immunoblotting procedures were utilized to assess cell signaling proteins associated with the regulation of FSR. We found that muscle FSR increased in the EAA+CHO group immediately following EAA+CHO ingestion (P0.05). Eukaryotic elongation factor 2 phosphorylation was reduced in both groups at 2 hr post-exercise (EAA+CHO: 39+/-7%; Fasting: 47+/-9%; P

Conclusion: We conclude that essential amino acids and carbs (EAA+CHO) ingestion prior to resistance exercise does not enhance post-exercise fractional synthesis rate (FSR–Fractional Synthetic Rate–aka rate of adding protein to muscles) as compared to exercise without nutrients.

My note–while this interesting, I would not dump your protein carb drink before lifting just yet. Based on info from Dave Barr (source, AI and personal conversation) moving it to 15 minutes before training may be more ideal. Stay tuned!

Gene expression profiling in human skeletal muscle during recovery from eccentric exercise.

Mahoney DJ, Safdar A, Parise G, Melov S, Fu M, MacNeil L, Kaczor J, Payne ET, Tarnopolsky MA. Department of Medical Sciences, McMaster University Medical Center, 1200 Main Street W., Hamilton, Ontario, Canada. We used cDNA microarrays to screen for differentially expressed genes during recovery from exercise-induced muscle damage in humans. Male subjects (n = 4) performed 300 maximal eccentric contractions, and skeletal muscle biopsy samples were analyzed at 3 h and 48 h after exercise. In total, 113 genes increased 3 h postexercise, and 34 decreased. At 48 h postexercise, 59 genes increased and 29 decreased. On the basis of these data, we chose 19 gene changes and conducted secondary analyses using real-time RT-PCR from muscle biopsy samples taken from 11 additional subjects who performed an identical bout of exercise.
Real-time RT-PCR analyses confirmed that exercise-induced muscle damage led to a rapid (3 h) increase in sterol response element binding protein 2 (SREBP-2), followed by a delayed (48 h) increase in the SREBP-2 gene targets Acyl CoA:cholesterol acyltransferase (ACAT)-2 and insulin-induced gene 1 (insig-1). The expression of the IL-1 receptor, a known regulator of SREBP-2, was also elevated after exercise. Taken together, these expression changes suggest a transcriptional program for increasing cholesterol and lipid synthesis and/or modification. Additionally, damaging exercise induced the expression of protein kinase H11, capping protein Z alpha (capZalpha), and modulatory calcineurin-interacting protein 1 (MCIP1), as well as cardiac ankryin repeat protein 1 (CARP1), DNAJB2, c-myc, and junD, each of which are likely involved in skeletal muscle growth, remodeling, and stress management.

Conclusion: In summary, using DNA microarrays and RT-PCR, we have identified novel genes that respond to skeletal muscle damage, which, given the known biological functions, are likely involved in recovery from and/or adaptation to damaging exercise.

My notes: I wonder why all this muscle physiology stuff is so elusive, to quote the authors “In total, 113 genes increased 3 h postexercise, and 34 decreased.” That is a lot of stuff going on! Still wondering if you need to damage the muscle for it to increase in size?

Post exercise carbohydrate-protein supplementation: phosphorylation of muscle proteins i
nvolved in glycogen synthesis and protein translation.

Ivy JL, Ding Z, Hwang H, Cialdella-Kam LC, Morrison PJ.Exercise Physiology and Metabolism Laboratory, Department of Kinesiology and Health Education, The University of Texas, Austin, Texas 78712-0360, USA. johnivy@mail.utexas.edu The enzymes Akt, mTOR, p70(S6K), rpS6, GSK3, and glycogen synthase interact in the control of protein and/or glycogen synthesis in skeletal muscle, and each has been found to respond to exercise and nutrient supplementation. In the present study, we tested the hypothesis that nutrient supplementation post exercise, in the form of a carbohydrate-protein (CHO-PRO) supplement, would alter the phosphorylation state of these enzymes in a manner that should increase muscle protein and glycogen synthesis above that produced by exercise alone. After a 45 min cycling session followed by sprints and again 15 min later, the subjects (n = 8) ingested 400 ml of a CHO-PRO drink (7.8% dextrose and 1.8% protein-electrolyte) or a placebo drink, as assigned using a randomized, counter-balanced design with repeated measures. Biopsies of the vastus lateralis were taken before exercise and at 45 min of recovery.
At 45 min after supplementation, CHO-PRO treatment yielded greater phosphorylation of Akt (65%), mTOR (86%), rpS6 (85-fold), and GSK3alpha/beta (57%) than pre-exercise levels (p

Conclusion: These results suggest that a post exercise carb and protein (CHO-PRO) supplement alters the phosporylation levels of the enzymes tested in a manner that should accelerate muscle glycogen synthesis and protein initiation during recovery from cycling exercise.

My notes: cool info, but I would like to see this carried out in the future to any performance changes. This would say that it should help. I am sure that is in the pipeline and there is some data already out in that area

The effects of ibuprofen on muscle hypertrophy, strength, and soreness during resistance training.

Krentz JR, Quest B, Farthing JP, Quest DW, Chilibeck PD. High doses of ibuprofen have been shown to inhibit muscle protein synthesis after a bout of resistance exercise. We determined the effect of a moderate dose of ibuprofen (400 mg.d-1) consumed on a daily basis after resistance training on muscle hypertrophy and strength. Twelve males and 6 females (~24 years of age) trained their right and left biceps on alternate days (6 sets of 4-10 repetitions), 5 d.week-1, for 6 weeks.
In a counter-balanced, double-blind design, they were randomized to receive 400 mg.d-1 ibuprofen immediately after training their left or right arm, and a placebo after training the opposite arm the following day. Before- and after-training muscle thickness of both biceps was measured using ultrasound and 1 repetition maximum (1 RM) arm curl strength was determined on both arms.
Subjects rated their muscle soreness daily. There were time main effects for muscle thickness and strength (p

Conclusion: We conclude that a moderate dose of ibuprofen ingested after repeated resistance training sessions does not impair muscle hypertrophy or strength and does not affect ratings of muscle soreness.

My Notes: If you would have asked me even a few months ago, I would have said that the use of NSAIDs (like Advil) is not a good idea as it may limit muscle growth (hypertrophy). After talking to some at ACSM, looking at some newer litature, I am thinking it will probably be ok. It may even be beneficial after an acute injury to keep your movement quality better and limit pain, thus reducing the chance on longer term chronic pain ala the neuromatrix of pain. See the following posts on that below

Pain Perception and the Neuromatrix–Guest Blog by Katelin Bigelow

Pre-emptive Analgescis–what is he talking about now?

Cellular and molecular events controlling skeletal muscle mass in response to altered use.

Favier FB, Benoit H, Freyssenet D.Unité Physiologie et Physiopathologie de l’Exercice et Handicap, IFR143, Université Jean Monnet, 15 rue Ambroise Paré, 42023, Saint Etienne, cedex 2, France.
Gain or loss of skeletal muscle mass occurs in situations of altered use such as strength training, aging, denervation, or immobilization. This review examines our current understanding of the cellular and molecular events involved in the control of muscle mass under conditions of muscle use and disuse, with particular attention to the effects of resistance exercise/training. The DNA content, which is a critical determinant of protein synthesis by providing the amount of DNA necessary to sustain gene transcription, can be either increased (activation of satellite cells) or decreased (apoptosis) depending on muscle activity and ongoing physiological processes. In addition, several transcription factors are sensitive to functional demand and may control muscle-specific protein expression to promote or repress myofiber enlargement. The control of skeletal muscle mass is also markedly mediated by the regulation of transduction pathways that promote the synthesis and/or the degradation of proteins. Insulin-like growth factor-I plays a key role in this balance by activating the Akt/tuberous sclerosis complex 2/mammalian target of rapamycin pathway.

Conclusion: Stimulation of this pathway leads to the concomitant activation of initiation and elongation factors resulting in the elevation of protein translation and the downregulation of ubiquitin proteasome components through Forkhead-box O transcription factors.

My Notes: Good review (with lots of big words), but the take away is still the same–USE IT OR LOSE IT!

Rock on
Mike N

Post to Twitter

4 Comments

Z Health in Minnesota for RKCs-Its Time and Testimonial

Greetings! I trust everyone had a great weekend. I went to the Saints game (semi pro) baseball game outside on a beautiful Friday night with friends and got to ride my new kiteboard on Saturday. I was not able to kite due to low winds, but did a short session of wake surfing behind the boat. Special thanks to Gary who made the board by hand and from scratch (it turned out beautiful) and Mike “SuperSize” for the pull behind the boat. Great times!!

The Physique Formula is Here
Jimmy Smith has finally released his new Physique Formula with some special bonuses for a limited time. Click HERE to check it out , or the picture on the uppder right of this blog. In the interest of dull disclosure I do make a few bucks off of each purchase (and the price to you the consumer is the same here or on Jimmy’s site).

Z Health Time for RKCs coming to Minnesota!
The RKC FMS is coming up soon–Aug 8-10 here in Minnesota, so if anyone is interested in a custom Z Health session from yours truly while you are in town, drop me a line. I only have a few appointment slots at this time, so first come first serve. See this link for all the details. Either way, drop me a line if you are going to be here as it is great to meet people again and meet others for the first time live and in person!

Professional Testimonial
“Mike Nelson is an extremely knowledgeable Zhealth instructor. His dry sense of humor, ability to convey the material and his focus on good form makes it easy to achieve your goals.”

Andrea DuCane
Master RKC
Z Health, Level 4 Instructor

Post to Twitter

No Comments

The Last Lecture: Must Read!


A little off topic today, but I just finished reading “The Last Lecture” by Randy Pausch 2 days ago. AMAZING!

It is about how to live out your dreams and just general great advice for life. It should be required reading for all and the best book I have read this year.

I just learned today that he actually passed away very recently. Do yourself a favor and pick up a copy for less than 15 clams. It is an easy read and is more than worth the time.
Mike N

Post to Twitter

5 Comments

Z Health Feedback and Question–Jaw Mobility?

Z Health Feedback and Question–Jaw Mobility?

Feedback/question
The Z is going well and I feel stronger every week.

Here is my thought of the day:

In the R Phase manual Dr Cobb describes the movements for this phase. It is good to have the what. What I really like to know is the why. That is the what I liked most about working with an actual Z Health trainer (you). I think that without the why, it is just going through motions aimlessly or blindly. You know there is supposed to be some good coming but no idea what.

With that said, what is the purpose of the TMJ (jaw mobility)?

Thanks,

Answer

Thanks for the comments! Much appreciated and great to hear from you.

The funny thing is, all the background and theory is actually in the first 25-30 pages of the Z Health R Phase manual (you can pick up a copy by clicking on the Z Health Performance picture on the upper right), but I did not get it after reading it a few times (is this ALL? was my first thought). Even after the entire R Phase training I read it over again and went–oh, I get it now. ha! So kudos to for trying to understand why.

In short, ANY jammed or less than optimal joint will create muscular weakness. See this link HERE

The trick is that since the nervous system takes feedback from ALL of the joints, even having one joint not up to par will affect overall performance. Yep, and this includes the jaw! For those that the Neural Warm Up or R Phase, you will find that every joint is covered.

The level 4, more whooo whooo answer is that the jaw work can have profound effects for those that need some cranial (head) work from past trauma usually or bad movement for years. The head and the hands/wrists are actually at the end of the force transfer from the feet too (that force has to go somewhere–remember Physics 101).

Any comments, let me know

Post to Twitter

No Comments

TRX Suspension Trainer: Train Like the Pros.

Powered by FeedBurner